Florida is having an embezzlement reckoning. In the twelve months ending May 2026, prosecutors in Miami-Dade, Martin, Volusia, and Orange counties brought criminal cases against community-association managers and HOA officers totaling more than $13 million in alleged theft. The marquee case — The Hammocks Community Association in West Kendall — ended on April 30, 2026 with a guilty plea from former HOA president Marglli Gallego to one count of racketeering and one count of grand theft, and a guilty plea from her husband Juan Antonio Gonzalez to money laundering. Gallego received seven years in state prison; the Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office described it as the longest known prison sentence imposed on an HOA board president. Behind the headlines is a pattern your board needs to internalize, because the rules that would have caught every one of these cases are already in Florida law — and most boards do not follow them.
This is general information about Florida community-association law and is not legal advice. If your board suspects fraud, contact your association's attorney and law enforcement immediately — do not investigate alone, and do not confront the suspected party before counsel weighs in. This guide covers condominium and cooperative associations under Chapters 718 and 719 and homeowners' associations under Chapter 720; the controls and statutes differ between them and the differences are flagged throughout.
The 2025-2026 Florida prosecution wave
Five Florida cases tell the story of the current enforcement climate. Each one was preventable by the controls already written into Florida law.
The Hammocks Community Association (Miami-Dade). The largest known HOA fraud in U.S. history. Marglli Gallego, 44, and her husband Juan Antonio Gonzalez, 49, pleaded guilty on April 30, 2026 to racketeering, grand theft, and money laundering. Per the Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office and confirmed by CBS Miami and The Real Deal's deep-dive reporting, prosecutors traced more than $11 million in diverted funds across an association that serves roughly 18,000 residents in 6,527 homes on 3,800 acres. The scheme had three legs: shell-company "vendors" that performed little or no actual work, "ghost employees" on the payroll who did no work, and real vendors who were overpaid in exchange for kickbacks. Gallego was sentenced to seven years in state prison plus seven years of probation. Gonzalez received seven years of probation, a $50,000 restitution check, and deeded a $1.2 million property in south Miami-Dade to the association. Eight defendants have been arrested in total since late 2022; four remain pending as of late May 2026.
Avant-Garde Property Management (Martin County). Alexandra Delacaridad Gonzalez, 46, of Miramar (no relation to the Hammocks defendant) turned herself in shortly after 2 a.m. on April 9, 2026 and was booked on 124 felony counts: two counts of fraud over $50,000, two counts of grand theft, 61 counts of uttering false instruments, and 59 counts of embezzlement and false entries in business records. Bond was set at $1,282,500. According to CBS12, Gonzalez worked as the property manager and bookkeeper for AvantGarde Property Management, with access to multiple HOA bank accounts. She allegedly stole nearly $200,000 from Whitemarsh Reserve Homeowners Association in Stuart and The Dunes of Hutchinson Island, by writing checks to herself, creating fictitious invoices, falsifying ledger entries, and forging signatures of authorized account holders. The funds went to cosmetic surgery, shopping sprees, and vacations to New York City and Disney World.
C & M Property Management (Martin County). Scott Michael Brechbill, owner of C & M Property Management, was arrested July 1, 2025 on grand theft, organized fraud, and related charges after a two-year Martin County Sheriff's Office investigation. The alleged scheme routed more than $800,000 of HOA funds — the largest single hit was over $820,000 from Quail Meadow HOA — through the company's operating account, which Brechbill allegedly used as personal funds from 2018 to 2023. Bond was set at $2.1 million.
New Smyrna Beach Club Condominium Association (Volusia). Julius Bruggeman, former president and manager, was charged in early 2025 with grand theft, organized scheme to defraud, and racketeering for misappropriating approximately $1 million over a decade. When investigators executed search warrants on May 1, 2024, Bruggeman's home had been emptied days before; he is believed to have fled to the Portland, Oregon area.
Stonebridge Place / MetroWest Master Association (Orlando). Tara Howie, former president, allegedly used HOA funds for personal bills and then attempted to cash a $743,000 cashier's check drawn against the association's reserves. The bank stopped the check and opened a fraud case. Civil litigation alleges she diverted roughly $750,000 into a personal-access account.
One law firm, Siegfried Rivera, has framed this as "law enforcement's new mindset" on community-association crime. The Hammocks racketeering charges (a Florida RICO posture not typical for HOA cases pre-2022) and the dedicated Miami-Dade Sheriff's Office Organized Crime Bureau Real Estate Fraud Squad taking the Roberto Montalvo Jr. case both confirm the trend. Florida prosecutors are now treating HOA theft as organized crime.
The patterns: how the money disappears
The cases share a small set of patterns. Recognize them and you recognize the gap in your own controls.
- Single person with unsupervised banking access. The Avantgarde, C&M, and Bruggeman cases all hinge on one person controlling the bank accounts with no real-time second pair of eyes.
- Shell-company "vendors." The Hammocks scheme used multiple shell entities, including family fronts, that invoiced the association for work that did not exist. Roughly $6 million of the diverted funds was paid to nonexistent or redundant services.
- "Ghost employees" on the payroll. Approximately $1.2 million was paid to people who did no work for the Hammocks.
- Falsified ledgers shown to the board. The board sees one set of books; the real records are hidden. The Hammocks defendants stored real records in a "bunker" beneath a ballroom hatch and at a spa storefront in a vacant strip mall.
- Forged signatures on checks. The most common method in the bookkeeper-style cases.
- Routing funds to a management-company operating account. Used as the gateway to personal funds in the Brechbill case.
- HOA debit/ATM cards. A Coachwood Colony case in Leesburg involved a former president who continued using the association debit card after resigning. ATM surveillance contradicted his defense. Eliminate association debit cards; there is no operational reason to have them.
- Recall or election interference. The Hammocks invalidated 1,900 of 2,900 owner signatures on a 2022 recall petition. Frustrated owners are a fraud signal — not a problem the board should be solving by tightening grip.
- Refusal of records / suing investigators. The Hammocks board charged police $11,500 for document production and sued the State Attorney to block subpoenas. Records resistance from inside the association is itself a red flag.
- Personal-lifestyle expenses bleeding through. Plastic surgery, vacations to Disney and New York, vet bills, wire transfers to Colombia. When the bank statement shows it, someone is going to see it — eventually.

The fidelity bond every board has — and most boards waive
Florida law requires every condominium and homeowners' association to carry insurance or a fidelity bond covering the people who handle association money. The HOA rule, FS 720.3033(5), reads:
"The association shall maintain insurance or a fidelity bond for all persons who control or disburse funds of the association. The insurance policy or fidelity bond must cover the maximum funds that will be in the custody of the association or its management agent at any one time."
The condominium parallel, FS 718.111(11)(h), uses identical language. Three things every board should pull from this. First, the obligation runs to the association — not to the CAM personally. Florida does not require community-association managers to carry their own fidelity bond. The association must extend the bond to cover the management agent's personnel. Second, the amount must equal the maximum funds in custody at any one time. Operating account balances plus reserves plus any pending special-assessment collections. A bond set at $50,000 when the reserves are $800,000 does not satisfy the statute. Third, the requirement can be waived annually by majority vote of the voting interests — but a waived bond is the single most common reason an association that suffers a loss does not recover anything.
The action item is short: pull the current insurance binder, confirm the bond is in force, confirm the coverage limit equals or exceeds the maximum association funds in custody, confirm the named insureds include the president, secretary, treasurer, every check signer, and the CAM and the CAM firm's personnel. If any line is missing, that is the first agenda item at the next board meeting.
Check controls: dual signatures and the no-debit-card rule
Florida law does not mandate two signatures on association checks, but the prosecutorial pattern makes the policy choice obvious. Adopt a written rule: every check above a stated threshold — common practice is $500 or $1,000 — requires two signatures, one of which is a director other than the manager. Below the threshold, single-signature checks may still be allowed for routine operating expenses, but the bank statement must still be reviewed monthly by a director.
Three operational rules that follow from the case record:
- No association debit or ATM cards. There is no legitimate operational need that cannot be met by a check, wire, ACH, or a credit card with limited authorization. Debit cards bypass the dual-signature rule and create an obvious vector for personal-use withdrawals.
- Wire and ACH transfers require board approval above a threshold. The same logic as dual-signature checks applies to electronic movement of money — even more so, because wires are faster and harder to reverse.
- Secure blank-check storage. Pre-printed signature stamps and access to blank checks are the two most direct enablers of forgery cases.
Document each of these in a written cash-handling policy. The policy itself becomes a defense for non-conspiring directors if fraud later occurs — it demonstrates the board exercised reasonable oversight.
Direct bank access for directors, not just the manager
This is the single highest-leverage control on the list. Every Florida association should arrange that at least two directors — typically the treasurer and one other director, ideally rotating — have direct read-only online access to every association bank and brokerage account. Not statements forwarded by the manager. Direct login.
Why direct access matters: the Hammocks defendants and the Avantgarde manager both produced doctored monthly statements to the board for years. The board saw what the manager wanted them to see. Direct read-only access removes the manager as the intermediary — the directors see what the bank actually says. The treasurer should reconcile the bank statement against the manager-produced general ledger monthly and report any variance to the board.
This control costs nothing — banks routinely set up multi-user read-only access. It catches every case in the prosecution wave. It also dovetails with the expanded official-records statute: bank statements and ledgers are now expressly enumerated official records under FS 720.303(4) and FS 718.111(12), so an owner is entitled to inspect them — meaning a director certainly is.
Try Mosaic alongside your current software. No Risk!
- Keep yourself compliant on every statute change
- Keep your board compliant across every workflow
- Keep your HOA compliant and your owners happy
The financial-reporting tiers and when an audit is mandatory
Florida's financial-reporting statutes were designed to make boards look at the books. For HOAs, FS 720.303(7), and for condominiums, FS 718.111(13), set the same four-tier ladder based on the association's total annual revenues:
- Under $150,000: a report of cash receipts and expenditures.
- $150,000 to $299,999: compiled financial statements.
- $300,000 to $499,999: reviewed financial statements.
- $500,000 or more: audited financial statements.
HB 1203 (2024) added a second trigger for HOAs: associations with 1,000 or more parcels must prepare audited financial statements regardless of revenue. Both HB 1021 (2024, condo) and HB 1203 (2024, HOA) tightened the ability to vote down to a lower level — reductions cannot happen in consecutive years, and HB 913 (2025) raised the bar further so that a downward vote requires a majority of all voting interests, not just those present. The deadline to complete the financial report was extended from 120 to 180 days after the fiscal year end.
For an association already at the audit threshold, the audit is not optional — and skipping it is a Chapter 720 / Chapter 718 violation. For an association below the threshold, an independent annual audit is still the strongest single control. The cost of an audit on a $400,000-revenue HOA runs four figures; the cost of an undetected manager bleeding the operating account for five years runs into the millions. Our companion guides on audit preparation and audit versus review cover the procedural side. The board's job is to make sure the auditor talks to the board directly, not through the manager.
Vendor controls, the $2,500 manager rule, and the kickback felony
The Hammocks scheme worked because the shell vendors invoiced an association that had no real vendor approval process. Florida's competitive-bidding statutes are the structural counter, and they were sharpened in 2024 and 2025.
The framework is in FS 718.3026 (condos — bidding required above 5% of total annual budget including reserves) and FS 720.3055 (HOAs — 10%), with director and relative conflicts of interest governed by FS 718.3027 and FS 720.3033. The companion guide on vendor contracts and competitive bidding walks through the full structure. Three points specifically relevant to embezzlement prevention:
- The $2,500 manager-conflict rule. Under FS 468.4335, as amended by HB 913 (2025), when a community-association manager, management firm, person with a financial interest in either, or relative of any such person bids more than $2,500 to provide non-management goods or services to the association, the board must solicit multiple bids from other third-party providers. This rule exists specifically to prevent the management-company-as-vendor pattern that sat at the center of the Brechbill case.
- The kickback felony. FS 720.3033(3) makes it a third-degree felony for an HOA officer, director, or manager to knowingly solicit, offer to accept, or accept a kickback. A "kickback" is defined broadly as anything or service of value not paid for. The carve-outs are narrow — sub-$25 food at a business meeting and trade-fair or education-program incidentals. Parallel rules apply on the condo side. A vendor-paid round of golf or a holiday case of wine is not a courtesy; it is a felony zone.
- The 20% voidable rule. Under FS 718.3027(5), a non-disclosed conflict-of-interest contract is voidable upon written notice from at least 20% of the voting interests of the association. This is the owner-side mechanism for unwinding a fraudulent vendor contract that the board approved without knowing about the conflict. Our conflict-of-interest guide covers the disclosure framework in depth.
Records discipline — and the new criminal penalties
HB 1021 (2024) and HB 1203 (2024) substantially expanded both the official-records list and the criminal penalties for tampering with those records. The list now expressly includes invoices, transaction receipts, deposit slips, bank statements, ledgers, bids, contracts, building permits, and director-education certificates. Bids must be retained at least one year from receipt; most other records, at least seven years. Larger associations — condos with 25+ units, HOAs with 100+ parcels — must also post core records on the association's website or application.
Three new criminal offenses came with the expanded list and matter directly for fraud cases:
- Destruction of official records during the seven-year retention period: first-degree misdemeanor.
- Failure to provide records within the statutory inspection window: second-degree misdemeanor.
- Refusal to provide records to avoid a criminal investigation: third-degree felony.
Before HB 1021, a board accused of fraud could shred the bank statements and face only a civil records-violation claim. Now the shredder triggers criminal exposure. The practical board takeaway: keep everything, archive electronically, and respond to owner record requests on time. Our records-request guide covers the inspection mechanics from the owner side.
When fraud is found: the response playbook
If the board's internal review — or an owner's tip, or an auditor's flag — reveals likely embezzlement, the sequence matters. Slow down here:
- Call the association's attorney first. Before talking to the suspected party, before changing locks, before issuing any public statement. Counsel will coordinate the criminal complaint, the insurance/bond claim, and the civil lawsuit so they do not undercut each other.
- Preserve the records. Pull and back up every relevant bank statement, ledger, invoice, and vendor contract before anyone with access has a chance to destroy them. Florida's new records-destruction criminal statute makes spoliation expensive, but you cannot rely on that — preserve immediately.
- Restrict access. Change online banking credentials. Add the required second signer. Suspend the suspected party's banking authority. This is a board action that should be minuted carefully.
- File the criminal complaint. Local law enforcement: the county sheriff's office, the State Attorney's economic-crimes unit, or in Miami-Dade the MDSO Organized Crime Bureau Real Estate Fraud Squad. Provide your preserved records and let law enforcement direct the investigation.
- File the DBPR complaint. If a CAM is implicated, the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation's Regulatory Council of Community Association Managers can discipline the license up to revocation. Complaints remain confidential until ten days after a finding of probable cause.
- Notice the fidelity bond / crime carrier. Late notice is the most common reason an insurance claim fails. Notify all carriers immediately.
- Communicate to owners through counsel. Owners will hear about it. The board's communication should come from a single, lawyer-vetted source, and should not name parties beyond what is in the public record.

Common board mistakes
Each of these is a recurring enabler of the prosecutions in the record:
- Letting the fidelity bond lapse or under-fund. A bond at $50,000 against $800,000 in reserves means the recovery channel does not exist when it is needed.
- Single-signer checks above the threshold. Dual signatures are the single cheapest control to adopt.
- Association debit or ATM cards. No legitimate purpose, real fraud risk.
- Bank statements only seen through the manager. Set up direct read-only access for directors today.
- Skipping the audit at the threshold. Mandatory under FS 720.303(7) and FS 718.111(13). Skipping is itself a violation.
- No independent vendor approval process. The Hammocks shell-vendor pattern requires this.
- Accepting vendor gifts. Sub-$25 meals only. The kickback statute is a felony, not a guideline.
- Records destruction or refusal. Now a misdemeanor or felony, depending on context.
- Late notice to insurance. The cheapest recovery path is also the easiest to forfeit.
- Confronting the suspect alone. Always through counsel and with law enforcement coordination — not in a Tuesday-night board meeting.
Key takeaways
- The fidelity bond is mandatory. FS 720.3033(5) and FS 718.111(11)(h) require coverage equal to the maximum funds in custody, including reserves. Confirm yours is in force, sufficient, and has not been waived.
- Two signatures, no debit cards, monthly board bank review. Three rules that would have caught every prosecution in the Florida wave.
- Direct bank access for directors. Read-only online access for at least two directors removes the manager-as-intermediary risk.
- The audit threshold is not optional. $500,000 revenue or 1,000 parcels triggers a mandatory audit under HB 1203 (2024). Skipping it is itself a violation.
- The $2,500 manager-conflict rule and the kickback felony. FS 468.4335 and FS 720.3033(3) are the structural counters to the manager-as-vendor and the vendor-gift patterns.
- Records destruction is now a crime. HB 1021 (2024) made shredding records during the retention period a misdemeanor and refusing records to obstruct an investigation a felony.
- If you find fraud, call counsel first. The criminal complaint, the insurance claim, and the civil suit have to be sequenced together — and notice to the carrier cannot be late.
Frequently asked questions
Share this guide