The number your board approves for concrete restoration is not the price. It is an estimate wearing the costume of a contract. Every other capital project you will run can be measured before you buy it. A roof has a known area. An elevator has a known count. Concrete restoration is priced as unit rates applied to estimated quantities of deterioration — and nobody knows the real quantity until crews start sounding and chipping. Boards that miss this sign a number, tell owners that number, and then spend two years explaining why it was wrong.
General information for Florida community associations, not legal or engineering advice. Structural repair decisions belong with a Florida-licensed engineer and your association’s attorney, working from your building’s own condition assessment.
Why concrete is not like the roof
If your board has already run a roof replacement, you have a mental model for capital projects: get an area, get a system, get three prices, pick one, manage the noise. That model breaks here.
Concrete restoration is the repair of structural concrete that has begun to fail from the inside. In Florida the mechanism is almost always chloride-induced corrosion: salt-laden air drives chloride ions through the concrete cover, the reinforcing steel inside starts to rust, and rust occupies far more volume than the steel it replaces. The expanding steel fractures the concrete from within. South Florida buildings commonly begin showing it within 15 to 20 years. It is the same deterioration behind the wave of eight-figure repair bills now reaching Florida condo owners.
The damage announces itself late. By the time a chunk of a balcony edge lets go, the corrosion has been running for years and has spread well beyond the visible break. Which is the whole problem: the quantity of work is hidden inside the structure you are pricing, and the only way to find it is to go looking, surface by surface.
A roofing contractor bids a known area for a lump sum. A restoration contractor bids a price per unit of repair against a quantity someone guessed. Change the guess and the project changes, even though the unit prices never move.
Just enough vocabulary
You do not need to understand concrete chemistry. You need to read an engineer’s report without nodding along, and compare two bids that use the same words to mean the same things. Six terms cover it.
| Term | What it means for your invoice |
|---|---|
| Spalling | Concrete that has broken away, usually exposing rusted steel. This is the visible damage — and the least of it. |
| Delamination | Concrete that has separated internally but has not fallen yet. Invisible from the surface. This is the quantity that decides your budget. |
| Sounding | Dragging a chain or tapping a hammer to hear where delamination hides. A clear ring means sound concrete; a dull hollow note means trouble underneath. |
| Chloride intrusion | The salt-driven cause. Relevant because it explains why damage keeps appearing after you thought you had found it all. |
| Unit price | The rate you pay per unit of work — per square foot of overhead repair, per linear foot of rebar replacement. This is what you are actually contracting for. |
| Allowance quantity | The estimated amount of each item, used to turn unit prices into a comparable bid total. It is a comparison device, not a promise. |
If you retain nothing else: unit prices are real and contractual; allowance quantities are estimates. Your final cost is unit price multiplied by whatever is actually found.
What waiting costs
Deferral is not neutral here, and this is the strongest argument a board has when owners push to keep assessments flat for another year. Industry estimates for Florida work put the curve roughly like this.
| Stage | Typical range | What is involved |
|---|---|---|
| Caught early | around $20 per sq ft | Patching before the steel is significantly compromised |
| Moderate | $50–$150 per sq ft | Removal back to sound concrete, rebar cleaning or replacement |
| Advanced | $150–$400+ per sq ft | Structural repair or member replacement after years of neglect |
These are contractor and engineering estimates rather than a published schedule, and your building’s numbers will depend on access, elevation and exposure. But the shape is consistent and it is the point: a tenfold to twentyfold penalty for waiting. Corrosion does not pause while a board debates, a point Florida association counsel make repeatedly — Becker catalogues the issues that typically end up controlling the association once a project is under way. Every year of deferral moves square footage from the cheap row to the expensive one, which is exactly the argument for funding structural reserves properly rather than treating them as a line to trim.
The quantity trap
This is where projects actually fail, and it fails in a way that looks responsible at every step.
The engineering firm SOCOTEC documents a Miami Beach high-rise that ran the sequence perfectly and still came apart. The engineer produced quantity estimates that were well below what a comparable building would normally require. The board, working to a budget it had already fixed, asked the engineer to reduce the quantities further so the numbers would fit. Contractors bid against those thin quantities — and protected themselves with high unit prices, which is the rational response to a scope you suspect is understated.
The contractor reached 100 percent of the budgeted amount having repaired fewer than one tenth of the building’s balconies.
Nobody in that story behaved outrageously. The board wanted a number owners could accept. The engineer accommodated the board. The contractor priced the risk it was being handed. The arithmetic did the rest.
- Setting the budget first. Deciding what owners will tolerate, then asking the scope to fit it. The scope always loses.
- Buying a cheap condition assessment. A visual walk finds spalling. Only sounding finds delamination, and delamination is the budget.
- Comparing bid totals instead of unit prices. Two bids built on different quantity assumptions are not comparable documents.
- Treating the total as a ceiling. It is a projection. The contract you signed is the unit rates.
The same source describes an association that budgeted $3–4 million for a recertification package covering concrete restoration, balcony railings, waterproofing, painting, elevator modernization and pool deck work, and received bids exceeding $8 million. Bundling several trades into one procurement makes the gap between expectation and reality wider, not narrower.
The survey that sets your budget
Everything downstream depends on one document: the condition assessment. Pay for a real one.
A proper assessment maps the building surface by surface and records delamination, spalling, cracking, corrosion staining and previous repairs that have failed — failed patches are common and they hide fresh damage. The core technique is sounding. On horizontal surfaces such as walkways and pool decks, a chain drag is pulled across the slab. On vertical and overhead surfaces such as columns, beams and balcony soffits, an engineer works across the area with a hammer. Sound concrete rings; delaminated concrete answers with a dull, hollow note. The International Concrete Repair Institute publishes the guidelines this work follows, jointly with the American Concrete Institute.
Two consequences for a board. First, sounding every accessible surface takes time and access, which means it costs money — and a proposal that is dramatically cheaper than the others is usually proposing less sounding. Second, an assessment done from the ground or from photographs is not an assessment. Balcony soffits and undersides are where the corrosion lives, and reaching them requires the same access equipment the repair will need. Permitting for both the access and the structural work runs through your local building department under the Florida Building Code, which is itself a scheduling constraint worth mapping early.
Retain the engineer before you speak to a contractor, and keep them independent of whoever performs the work. A contractor who scopes their own project has no incentive to find less of it. The engineer defines the scope, sets quantities, writes the specification, evaluates bids and administers the contract during construction. Usefully, FS 718.3026 exempts professional services such as engineers and architects from the competitive bidding requirement, so you can select on merit — while the construction contract itself must be bid.
Getting bids you can actually compare
Under FS 718.3026, a contract exceeding 5 percent of the association’s total annual budget including reserves must be bid competitively. A restoration project will clear that threshold in almost every building. The statute does not require you to take the lowest bid, and on this kind of work you frequently should not.
The specification is what makes bids comparable. Insist on the following.
- Unit price bidding on every primary item — concrete removal and replacement per square foot, overhead versus vertical versus horizontal priced separately because they cost differently, rebar replacement per linear foot, crack routing and sealing per linear foot, waterproofing and coatings per square foot.
- Identical allowance quantities issued by your engineer, used by every bidder for the sole purpose of producing a comparable total. Never let bidders supply their own quantities.
- A single specification so bidders are pricing the same repair details, materials and testing.
- Mobilization, access and equipment priced separately from repair work — swing stages and scaffolding are a large fixed cost that has nothing to do with quantities.
- A stated measurement protocol: who measures completed quantities, how, how often, and how disputes are resolved. Get this wrong and you will argue about it monthly for a year and a half. Practical guidance on running the procurement is published in the Florida Community Association Journal.
- Unit prices held firm for the duration, or escalated on a defined and disclosed basis.
When bids arrive, read across the unit prices rather than down to the totals. A bidder who is low on the total but high on overhead repair per square foot has priced the job they expect to find, not the job you published. Our guide to vendor contracts and bidding covers the procurement mechanics that apply to any large association contract.
Try Mosaic alongside your current software. No Risk!
- Keep yourself compliant on every statute change
- Keep your board compliant across every workflow
- Keep your HOA compliant and your owners happy
Fund the overrun, not the bid
Because the bid is a projection, the funding plan has to be built for a number larger than the bid. Boards that fund exactly the bid total are guaranteeing a second, angrier conversation with owners partway through the work.
The three sources, and how they behave here:
Reserves
- Structural items in a structural integrity reserve study are precisely what these funds exist for.
- Permission is rarely the obstacle; sufficiency is.
- Reserves funded against a study that understated deterioration will not cover a project whose quantities came in high.
Special assessment and loans
- A special assessment is fenced to its stated purpose, so state the purpose broadly enough to cover the whole scope.
- An association loan spreads the cost and buys time, at interest.
- Most boards use a combination. Decide the structure before signing, not after the first overrun.
Two knock-on effects worth planning for. Deferred structural work and thin reserves are among the things that push buildings onto lender ineligibility lists, so the project has consequences for every seller in the building — see our guide to the condo lending blacklist. And completed structural repair is a fact your insurer should hear about at renewal, alongside the other underwriting evidence discussed in our insurance premium guide.
What needs an owner vote
Boards routinely delay necessary repairs believing they need owner approval to start. Usually they do not.
FS 718.113(1) makes maintenance, repair and replacement of the condominium property the association’s own responsibility. The 75 percent owner approval in FS 718.113(2)(a) applies to material alterations and substantial additions where the declaration is silent — a different thing from putting a deteriorated structure back as it was.
The line gets crossed when a board bundles improvements into the repair. Restoring a spalled balcony slab is maintenance. Replacing the railings with a different design, changing the building’s appearance, or adding something that was not there is where alteration analysis begins. That does not mean you cannot do it — it means you need to know which parts of your scope are which, and take it past your association’s attorney before the contract is signed rather than after an owner objects — firms such as Kaye Bender Rembaum publish board-facing guidance on where that line sits.
- Under FS 553.899(11), repairs addressing substantial structural deterioration must be commenced within 365 days after the local enforcement agency receives the phase two milestone inspection report.
- If the association cannot show repairs scheduled or commenced, the agency reviews whether the building is unsafe for human occupancy.
- Procurement on a project this size — assessment, specification, bidding, contracting, permitting — can consume most of that year on its own.
- Start the day the phase two report lands, not the day the deadline is noticed.
Living through it
The governance problem does not end at the contract. Restoration is unusually intrusive, and the association absorbs every complaint.
Industry practice puts a single balcony repair at roughly three weeks and a full facade restoration on a twenty-storey building at around eighteen months. Say that number at the beginning. Owners will forgive a long project they were warned about and will not forgive a short one that quietly became long.
What owners will actually experience
- Swing stages or scaffolding outside windows, elevation by elevation
- Balconies out of use for weeks, sometimes months
- Chipping noise during working hours — genuinely loud
- Furniture and planters cleared from balconies on notice
- Dust, and workers with a view into units
What a board should put in place first
- A written schedule by elevation, updated as it moves
- A single named contact for owner issues
- Notice periods for balcony clearance, in writing
- Guidance for owners with tenants, who bear the disruption without a vote
- Resale and estoppel disclosure while the project and its funding are live
Tenants deserve particular thought. They did not vote on the assessment and cannot, but they lose the balcony and get the noise. Buildings with a large rental population should expect a second wave of complaints routed through owners who are themselves not on site.
The rules behind this
| Rule | Source |
|---|---|
| Maintenance, repair and replacement of the condominium property is the association’s responsibility; the 75 percent approval requirement applies to material alterations and substantial additions where the declaration is silent. | FS 718.113(1), (2)(a) |
| Contracts exceeding 5 percent of the total annual budget including reserves must be competitively bid; the association need not accept the lowest bid; professional services including engineers and architects are excluded. | FS 718.3026 |
| Milestone inspection applies to buildings three habitable stories or more at 30 years, then every 10 years; a local agency may require 25 years based on factors including proximity to salt water. | FS 553.899(3) |
| Phase two is required only where substantial structural deterioration is identified, may involve destructive or nondestructive testing, and is reported by progress report within 180 days. | FS 553.899(7) |
| Repairs for substantial structural deterioration must be commenced within 365 days after the local enforcement agency receives the phase two report, failing which the agency reviews whether the building is unsafe for human occupancy. | FS 553.899(11) |
| Structural integrity reserve study items — including load-bearing walls, floor, foundation, and exterior structural elements — must be reserved for and may not be waived. | FS 718.112(2)(g) |
| Sounding by chain drag and hammer to locate delamination; repair methods and condition assessment practice. | ICRI guidelines and the ACI Concrete Repair Manual |
Frequently asked questions
Share this guide