If you've ever bought a home in a planned community, you've seen the letters "CC&R" somewhere in your closing paperwork. And if you've ever complained about a rule you didn't agree to, someone probably told you "that's your HOA." But CC&Rs and HOAs are not the same thing — and understanding the difference gives you real power when navigating disputes, board decisions, and your rights as a Florida homeowner.
One is a recorded legal document. The other is the organization that enforces it. Confusing them — as most homeowners do — can cost you leverage when challenging a bylaw amendment, disputing a fine, or questioning whether your board actually has the authority to do what it's doing. This guide covers what CC&Rs are, how they differ from an HOA, and why the distinction matters under Florida law.
What are CC&Rs — and what is an HOA?
CC&R stands for Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions. It is a legal document — formally called the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions — that a developer records with the county before selling the first lot in a planned community. In Florida, the official term is simply the "Declaration." You'll find it referenced throughout Florida Statute Chapter 720 (the Homeowners' Association Act) and Chapter 718 (the Condominium Act). The term "CC&Rs" comes from California real estate practice but Florida courts and statutes use "Declaration."
The Declaration is recorded with the Clerk of the Circuit Court in the county where the community is located. Once recorded, it provides constructive notice to every future buyer — meaning you are legally bound by its terms even if nobody personally handed you a copy.
An HOA — homeowners association — is something different entirely. It is a corporate entity, usually organized as a Florida not-for-profit corporation under Chapter 617. It is the organization created to manage the community, maintain common areas, collect assessments, and enforce the rules in the Declaration. Think of it this way:
- The CC&Rs (Declaration) = the rulebook
- The HOA = the organization that enforces the rulebook
The Declaration creates the authority. The HOA is the mechanism for exercising it. The CC&Rs typically contain language establishing the association and requiring every property owner to be a member as a condition of ownership.
CC&Rs are attached to the property, not to the person. When you buy a home in a deed-restricted community, you inherit every covenant the developer recorded — plus every amendment the community has passed since. It doesn't matter that you didn't vote on them or weren't living there when they were adopted. They bind every successive owner automatically.
The key differences between CC&Rs and an HOA
| CC&Rs (Declaration) | HOA (Association) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A recorded legal document | A corporate organization |
| Legal basis | Real property law (equitable servitudes) | Corporate law (FL Ch. 617) |
| Created by | The developer, before the first sale | The developer, via Articles of Incorporation |
| Filed where | Clerk of the Circuit Court (county land records) | Florida Division of Corporations (Secretary of State) |
| Who it binds | Every property owner, automatically | Every property owner is a mandatory member |
| How it changes | 2/3 vote of all owners + county recording | Bylaws: majority vote; Rules: board vote only |
| Can exist alone? | Yes — older subdivisions have CC&Rs with no HOA | Technically yes, but an HOA without CC&Rs has no enforcement power |
The governing document hierarchy in Florida
Florida law establishes a clear pecking order for all the documents that govern a community. Under F.S. 720.3075, if two documents conflict, the one higher in the hierarchy wins — every time.
| Level | Document | What It Controls |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Federal law (Fair Housing Act, ADA) | Anti-discrimination, accessibility |
| 2 | Florida statutes (Ch. 720 / Ch. 718) | HOA powers, owner rights, financial reporting, elections |
| 3 | Declaration / CC&Rs | Use restrictions, assessments, architectural standards, maintenance duties |
| 4 | Articles of Incorporation | Creates the HOA as a legal entity |
| 5 | Bylaws | Board meetings, elections, officer duties, quorum requirements |
| 6 | Rules & Regulations | Day-to-day operational policies (pool hours, parking, guest rules) |
If your board passes a rule that contradicts your CC&Rs, the rule is unenforceable. If your CC&Rs contain a provision that conflicts with Florida statute, the statute wins. And if a covenant violates the Fair Housing Act — say, a discriminatory residency restriction from the 1950s — federal law overrides it completely, even if the covenant has never been formally amended.
What CC&Rs typically contain
CC&Rs are often 30 to 60 pages long and written in dense legal language. But most of what affects your daily life falls into a few major categories:
Use restrictions
- Residential use only (no commercial activity)
- Rental restrictions and minimum lease terms
- Pet rules (type, size, number)
- Vehicle restrictions (no RVs, boats, or commercial vehicles in driveways)
- Short-term rental prohibitions
- Noise and nuisance provisions
Architectural standards
- Exterior paint colors, materials, roof types
- Fence height, style, and material
- Landscaping standards and approved plantings
- Approval process for modifications (ARC review)
- Setback requirements beyond local zoning
Financial authority
- Power to levy regular assessments (dues)
- Special assessment procedures and limits
- Lien rights for unpaid assessments (F.S. 720.3085)
- Late fees and interest provisions
Maintenance & enforcement
- What the HOA maintains vs. what the owner maintains
- Fining authority and due process (F.S. 720.305 requires a fining committee)
- Easements for utilities, access, and drainage
- Insurance requirements
- Dispute resolution procedures
How CC&Rs are amended in Florida
Changing the Declaration is intentionally hard. Under F.S. 720.306, the default threshold for amending a Florida HOA Declaration is two-thirds of the total voting interests — not two-thirds of those who show up to a meeting, but two-thirds of everyone eligible to vote in the entire community.
For a 100-unit HOA, that means you need at least 67 owners to vote yes — even if only 80 attend the meeting. Some Declarations set an even higher threshold (75% is common). A few provisions may require unanimous consent, particularly those affecting individual property boundaries or ownership percentages.
Compare that to how other governing documents change:
| Document | Who votes | Typical threshold | Must be recorded? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Declaration / CC&Rs | All owners | 2/3 of total voting interests | Yes — county Clerk of Court |
| Bylaws | All owners | Majority of voting interests | No |
| Rules & Regulations | Board only | Board majority vote | No |
When a board tells you "we changed the rule," ask whether they changed a rule (board vote, relatively easy) or the Declaration (community-wide supermajority vote, recorded with the county). If the restriction in question comes from the Declaration, a board resolution alone cannot change it — no matter what the board claims.
Try Mosaic alongside your current software. No Risk!
- Keep yourself compliant on every statute change
- Keep your board compliant across every workflow
- Keep your HOA compliant and your owners happy
When CC&Rs can be challenged or expire
CC&Rs are presumed valid — but they are not untouchable. The Florida Supreme Court established in Woodside Village Condominium Ass'n v. Jahren (2002) that a Declaration is the community's "constitution" and will be enforced unless unreasonable. But several grounds exist for challenging specific provisions:
Conflict with law
CC&Rs cannot override state or federal law. Florida has carved out specific protections that HOAs cannot restrict: pickup trucks in driveways (HB 1203, effective July 2024), solar panel installation, U.S. flag display, clotheslines, and EV charging stations.
Selective enforcement
The Florida Supreme Court held in White Egret Condominium, Inc. v. Franklin (1979) that CC&Rs must be "enforced uniformly or not at all." If the HOA fines you for a violation while ignoring the same violation by your neighbor, you have a defense. In Prisco v. Forest Villas (2003), a pet ban was struck down because the HOA enforced it against dog owners but ignored cat owners.
Discrimination
Any covenant that violates the Fair Housing Act is void — race, religion, national origin, gender, disability, familial status. Many pre-1968 CC&Rs still contain discriminatory language on paper. Multiple states have passed laws requiring HOAs to formally remove these provisions from their documents.
CC&Rs without an HOA
Many older Florida subdivisions have CC&Rs with no HOA to enforce them. In those communities, enforcement falls to individual neighbors through private lawsuits — expensive and rare, which is why covenants in these communities tend to erode over time. The reverse (an HOA without CC&Rs) leaves the association with no legal teeth.
The 30-year expiration trap: Florida's Marketable Record Title Act
Florida's Marketable Record Title Act (F.S. 712.01-712.10) was designed to clear old, obsolete interests from property titles. But it has an unintended consequence: if a community's Declaration was recorded more than 30 years ago and the HOA did not file a "Notice of Preservation" or re-record the Declaration within that window, the covenants can be extinguished entirely.
- The HOA loses its authority to enforce restrictions
- Assessments become unenforceable
- An individual homeowner can file a quiet title action (F.S. 712.05) to formally remove the covenants from their property
- The community effectively becomes unrestricted
In Holly Lake Ass'n v. Federal National Mortgage Ass'n (1995), the Florida Supreme Court held that covenants were extinguished because no preserving notice had been filed within the 30-year window. The legislature responded in 2004 by adding F.S. 720.3032, which gives HOAs a specific mechanism to preserve their Declaration against MRTA by recording a summary notice.
If your community was established before 1996, ask your HOA attorney whether a MRTA preservation notice has been filed. If it hasn't, this should be the board's top priority. The filing is straightforward and inexpensive compared to the catastrophic consequence of losing your covenants entirely.
How to read your CC&Rs: a practical guide
Your Declaration is probably the most important legal document related to your home that you never read. Here's how to approach it without a law degree:
Read these sections first
- Use restrictions — what you can and cannot do with your property (rentals, pets, home businesses, parking, exterior appearance)
- Architectural control — what requires approval before you modify anything, who approves, and how long they have to respond
- Assessment obligations — your regular dues, special assessment procedures, and what happens if you don't pay
- Maintenance responsibilities — where the HOA's obligation ends and yours begins (this is the source of countless disputes)
- Enforcement and penalties — the fining process, your hearing rights, and lien provisions
- Amendment procedures — the threshold required to change the rules
You can skim these
- Mortgagee/lender rights clauses (protect banks, not homeowners)
- Boilerplate legal definitions (unless a specific term is in dispute)
- Original developer rights and transition provisions (usually expired)
- Easement descriptions (relevant only if a specific access issue arises)
Pro tip: Check when your CC&Rs were last amended. If the document hasn't been touched in 20+ years, some provisions may conflict with current Florida law. The statute wins in those cases, but it helps to know where the gaps are.
Source: Community Associations Institute, 2023 Statistical Review
Frequently asked questions
Share this guide
